Wood shakes have been a favorite roofing material for centuries, valued for their natural charm and rustic appearance. But traditional wood shakes come with challenges: rot, insect damage, high maintenance, and a relatively short lifespan. That’s where metal shake roofing comes in.
Designed to replicate the look of natural wood while delivering the resilience of steel or aluminum, metal shake roofing has grown in popularity among homeowners seeking a balance of aesthetics and performance. In this guide, we’ll cover the advantages and disadvantages of metal shake roofing, explore cost considerations, and share design inspiration for modern and traditional homes.
What is Metal Shake Roofing?
Metal shake roofing is made from steel or aluminum panels stamped or pressed into the shape of hand-split wood shakes. These panels are often coated with a high-performance paint system (like PVDF) or stone-coated with granules for added texture and color variation.
Features include:
-
Deep shadow lines for a natural wood look.
-
Multiple color options, from weathered browns to cool grays.
-
Interlocking panel systems for durability against wind and rain.
-
Lightweight construction, far lighter than cedar, concrete, or slate.
Pros of Metal Shake Roofing
1. Exceptional Durability
Unlike wood shakes, metal shake panels won’t rot, split, or warp. They resist mold, mildew, pests, and fire — major weaknesses of natural wood.
2. Longevity
Metal shake roofs often last 40–70 years, far outlasting cedar shakes (15–25 years on average).
3. Low Maintenance
Periodic inspections and minor touch-ups are usually all that’s required, unlike wood shakes that demand cleaning, sealing, and regular replacement.
4. Lightweight Yet Strong
Metal shakes weigh a fraction of concrete or slate but can handle extreme weather, including hail and high winds.
5. Energy Efficiency
Many systems use reflective coatings that reduce heat absorption, lowering cooling costs.
6. Eco-Friendly
Metal roofing is recyclable at the end of its life, and many systems contain recycled content.
7. Curb Appeal
Metal shakes are designed to mimic natural wood so closely that most passersby can’t tell the difference — especially when stone-coated finishes are used.
Cons of Metal Shake Roofing
1. Upfront Cost
Metal shakes are more expensive than asphalt shingles and sometimes pricier than wood shakes, depending on the brand and finish.
2. Professional Installation Required
Improper installation can compromise performance and warranties. It’s essential to use contractors trained in metal roofing systems.
3. Potential for Dents
While highly impact-resistant, large hailstones can sometimes dent panels. Stone-coated versions tend to hide dents better than smooth panels.
4. Noise Concerns
Without proper underlayment or attic insulation, some homeowners notice more noise during heavy rain. Fortunately, modern underlayments minimize this issue.
Metal Shake Roofing Cost
Pricing varies depending on material, finish, roof complexity, and location.
-
Materials only: $5.50 – $9.00 per sq. ft.
-
Installed total: $12.00 – $18.00 per sq. ft.
Costs can rise if your roof has complex valleys, dormers, or multiple penetrations. However, the long-term value is strong since metal shake roofing can last 2–3 times longer than cedar shakes or asphalt shingles.
Design Inspiration with Metal Shakes
One of the biggest advantages of metal shake roofing is its design versatility. It fits seamlessly with many architectural styles:
1. Craftsman Homes
Weathered brown or chestnut-colored shakes enhance the warm, natural materials used in Craftsman-style architecture.
2. Mountain Cabins
Deep, rustic tones paired with stone and timber framing create a lodge-like feel with durability for snowy climates.
3. Coastal Homes
Stone-coated metal shakes in lighter gray or sand colors resist salt corrosion while complementing coastal palettes.
4. Modern Farmhouse
Charcoal or matte black shakes deliver a rustic-yet-modern aesthetic, pairing beautifully with board-and-batten siding.
5. Traditional Suburban Homes
Metal shakes in cedar blends offer a timeless appearance that elevates curb appeal while reducing maintenance.
Metal Shake vs. Other Roofing Options
| Feature | Metal Shake | Wood Shake | Asphalt Shingle |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lifespan | 40–70 years | 15–25 years | 15–30 years |
| Maintenance | Low | High (sealing, cleaning) | Moderate |
| Fire Resistance | Class A (with proper underlayment) | Poor unless treated | Good |
| Weight | Light | Moderate to heavy | Light |
| Cost (Installed) | $12–$18 per sq. ft. | $9–$14 per sq. ft. | $5–$8 per sq. ft. |
| Aesthetic Appeal | High (wood-like appearance) | High (authentic natural look) | Moderate to high |
Installation Considerations
-
Underlayment: Premium synthetic underlayment with ice and water barriers in cold climates.
-
Ventilation: Ensure balanced intake and exhaust for attic health.
-
Fasteners: Use corrosion-resistant fasteners specified by the manufacturer.
-
Snow Guards: In snowy climates, snow retention systems may be needed to prevent sudden roof slides.
-
Professional Installers: Always choose certified metal roofing installers to maintain warranties.
Maintenance Tips for Metal Shake Roofing
-
Inspect annually for debris buildup in valleys and around flashings.
-
Keep gutters and downspouts clear.
-
Rinse roof surface with low-pressure water if dust or pollen accumulates.
-
Avoid walking directly on the roof unless necessary; step on the low parts of the profile when required.
-
Check after major storms for displaced components or sealant wear.
Is Metal Shake Roofing Right for You?
Metal shake roofing is a great choice if you want the look of natural wood shakes without the headaches of rot, pests, and ongoing maintenance. It’s especially beneficial for:
-
Homes in hail-prone or storm-heavy regions.
-
Fire-risk areas where traditional wood is unsafe.
-
Coastal or mountain homes needing premium protection.
-
Homeowners looking for a long-term investment with low upkeep.
If budget is your top concern, asphalt shingles will be cheaper upfront, but they won’t match the lifespan or long-term savings of metal shakes.
Final Thoughts
Metal shake roofing combines the best of both worlds: the rustic beauty of traditional shakes with the modern strength of steel. While the initial cost is higher than asphalt or wood, the decades of durability, energy efficiency, and low maintenance often make it the smarter long-term choice.
Whether you’re restoring a mountain cabin, upgrading a coastal home, or adding rustic charm to a suburban house, metal shakes can elevate your roof’s appearance while delivering unmatched performance.
