When it comes to roofing materials, two of the most common options homeowners consider are metal roof tiles and asphalt shingles. While shingles dominate much of the residential market due to their affordability and wide availability, metal roof tiles are becoming increasingly popular for homeowners who want a longer-lasting, premium option that doesn’t sacrifice curb appeal.
If you’re trying to decide between these two, this in-depth guide will compare durability, cost, energy efficiency, maintenance, aesthetics, and long-term value so you can make the best choice for your home.
1. Durability and Lifespan
-
Metal Roof Tiles
-
Lifespan: 40–70 years, sometimes longer with proper care.
-
Resistant to rot, mold, mildew, and pests.
-
High fire resistance (Class A with proper assembly).
-
Withstands hail, wind gusts up to 140 mph, and heavy snow loads.
-
-
Asphalt Shingles
-
Lifespan: 15–30 years, depending on quality.
-
Vulnerable to curling, cracking, and granule loss.
-
Susceptible to algae, moss, and moisture damage in humid climates.
-
Less resistant to extreme weather than metal.
-
Verdict: Metal roof tiles clearly win on longevity and toughness.
2. Cost Comparison
-
Metal Roof Tiles
-
Materials: $6.00–$9.00 per sq. ft.
-
Installed: $12.00–$18.00 per sq. ft.
-
Higher upfront cost but fewer replacements over time.
-
-
Asphalt Shingles
-
Materials: $1.50–$3.50 per sq. ft.
-
Installed: $5.00–$8.00 per sq. ft.
-
Lower upfront cost but may require 2–3 replacements within the lifespan of one metal roof.
-
Verdict: Asphalt shingles are more affordable upfront; metal roof tiles are more cost-effective over the long run.
3. Energy Efficiency
-
Metal Roof Tiles
-
Reflect solar heat, especially with cool-roof coatings.
-
Can reduce cooling costs by 10–25% in hot climates.
-
Work well with radiant barriers and ventilated batten systems.
-
-
Asphalt Shingles
-
Absorb heat, especially in dark colors.
-
Minimal reflectivity and higher cooling costs.
-
Performance can improve with lighter shingle colors but still inferior to metal.
-
Verdict: Metal roof tiles provide better energy efficiency.
4. Environmental Impact
-
Metal Roof Tiles
-
Fully recyclable at the end of their lifespan.
-
Often made with recycled content.
-
Long service life reduces material waste.
-
-
Asphalt Shingles
-
Difficult to recycle due to tar and fiberglass composition.
-
Millions of tons of shingle waste enter landfills annually.
-
Verdict: Metal roof tiles are the eco-friendly option.
5. Aesthetic Appeal
-
Metal Roof Tiles
-
Designed to mimic traditional materials like clay, slate, or wood shake.
-
Available in a wide variety of colors and textures.
-
Maintain color longer with fade-resistant coatings.
-
-
Asphalt Shingles
-
Widely available in many colors and styles.
-
Premium architectural shingles provide added depth.
-
Tend to fade over time and lose granules, affecting curb appeal.
-
Verdict: Both offer aesthetic versatility, but metal roof tiles maintain appearance longer.
6. Maintenance Needs
-
Metal Roof Tiles
-
Minimal maintenance required beyond routine inspections.
-
Resistant to algae, moss, and insect damage.
-
May require occasional touch-ups on coatings or fasteners.
-
-
Asphalt Shingles
-
Require more frequent maintenance.
-
Vulnerable to granule loss, curling, and moss buildup.
-
Repairs are often patchwork and can compromise uniformity.
-
Verdict: Metal roof tiles require less maintenance.
7. Weather Resistance
-
Metal Roof Tiles
-
Excellent for high wind, hail, fire, and snow.
-
Shed snow easily in cold climates.
-
With proper coatings, resist salt corrosion in coastal regions.
-
-
Asphalt Shingles
-
Can blow off in high winds.
-
Less impact resistant.
-
Freeze-thaw cycles can shorten lifespan.
-
Verdict: Metal roof tiles are superior for weather resistance.
8. Long-Term ROI
-
Metal Roof Tiles
-
Higher initial investment but fewer replacements.
-
Can increase resale value due to durability and energy efficiency.
-
Insurance discounts often available for Class 4 impact resistance.
-
-
Asphalt Shingles
-
Lower upfront cost but more frequent replacements raise total lifetime expense.
-
Less likely to add resale value compared to premium roofing systems.
-
Verdict: Metal roof tiles offer better return on investment long-term.
When to Choose Metal Roof Tiles
-
You want a roof to last 40+ years.
-
You live in an area with frequent storms, hail, or wildfires.
-
You care about energy efficiency and eco-friendliness.
-
You’re willing to invest more upfront for long-term savings.
When to Choose Asphalt Shingles
-
Budget is your primary concern.
-
You plan to sell your home in less than 10 years.
-
You need a quick and cost-effective solution.
Final Thoughts
Both metal roof tiles and asphalt shingles have their place in the roofing market. Asphalt shingles win in affordability and availability, making them the go-to option for many homeowners on a budget. But for those who want superior durability, aesthetics, energy efficiency, and long-term value, metal roof tiles are the better choice.
