If you want a premium roof that looks like upscale shingles but performs like metal, stone-coated steel shingles are one of the best categories to consider. Two of the most researched options in that category are DECRA Shingle XD and Westlake Granite Ridge.
Both are premium metal shingle systems designed to deliver long service life, strong weather resistance, and a high-end residential appearance. The right choice depends on what you value most: visual style, hail risk, roof geometry, installation realities, and how you think about resale value.
Helpful pages on Top Tier Metals as you read
Metal Shingle Roofing: https://toptiermetals.com/collections/metal-shingle-roofing
DECRA Shingle XD: https://toptiermetals.com/products/decra-shingle-xd
Westlake Granite Ridge Shingle: https://toptiermetals.com/products/granite-ridge-shingle
DECRA Metal Roofing: https://toptiermetals.com/collections/decra-metal-roofing
Westlake Metal Roofing: https://toptiermetals.com/collections/westlake-metal-roofing
Quick verdict
Choose DECRA Shingle XD if you want
-
A clean, consistent premium shingle look that reads upscale from the street
-
A widely recognized stone-coated steel brand with broad market familiarity
-
A timeless appearance that fits many home styles without looking trendy
Choose Westlake Granite Ridge if you want
-
A more dimensional shingle aesthetic with stronger texture and shadow lines
-
A bolder curb appeal upgrade on highly visible roof planes
-
A roof that looks more like a design feature than a standard material choice
What these products are (plain English)
DECRA Shingle XD
DECRA Shingle XD is a stone-coated steel shingle profile designed to deliver the familiar shingle look while providing metal roofing durability.
Product page: https://toptiermetals.com/products/decra-shingle-xd
Westlake Granite Ridge Shingle
Westlake Granite Ridge is a stone-coated steel shingle profile designed for more pronounced dimensional texture and depth.
Product page: https://toptiermetals.com/products/granite-ridge-shingle
Both live in the premium metal shingle category here
https://toptiermetals.com/collections/metal-shingle-roofing
Side-by-side comparison
1) Curb appeal and architectural fit
DECRA Shingle XD look and feel
-
Typically reads as crisp, refined, and consistent across large roof planes
-
Works well across many home styles because it does not force a specific design theme
-
Strong fit when you want a premium upgrade that still feels familiar to most buyers
Westlake Granite Ridge look and feel
-
Emphasizes depth and texture more aggressively
-
Can be especially attractive on homes with prominent rooflines, high visibility angles, and strong curb presence
-
Strong fit when you want the roof to stand out visually rather than blend in
Resale value note
Resale value is driven less by brand trivia and more by buyer perception. Buyers notice what they can see: is the roof attractive, consistent, premium-looking, and clearly well-installed. In conservative neighborhoods, a cleaner shingle look often has broader acceptance. In neighborhoods where bold exterior upgrades are common, a more dimensional look can create stronger curb appeal lift.
2) Durability and long-term ownership
Stone-coated steel shingles are usually chosen for one core reason: long service life with a residential appearance. In real outcomes, the bigger durability differentiator is usually not the marketing claim on the box. It is project execution:
-
Installation quality
-
Flashing and transition detailing
-
Roof ventilation and overall roof assembly
-
The number of penetrations and complex intersections on the roof
Practical takeaway
If your roof has many valleys, dormers, skylights, or complex transitions, your best decision is the system you can detail correctly and consistently. A premium product paired with poor detailing becomes a long-term problem regardless of brand.
If you want to explore more premium options by brand
DECRA: https://toptiermetals.com/collections/decra-metal-roofing
Westlake: https://toptiermetals.com/collections/westlake-metal-roofing
3) Hail and impact considerations
Homeowners often ask: which one is better for hail
A better question is: how likely is cosmetic damage on my roofline, and how important is long-term appearance to me
Stone-coated surfaces can help reduce the visibility of minor impacts compared to some smooth-faced metal systems, depending on hail severity and exposure. However, extreme hail can damage any roof material.
Practical recommendation for hail-prone regions
-
Prioritize a system that can be detailed properly for your roof geometry
-
Choose the profile that will maintain appearance on the roof planes you see most from the street
-
Reduce avoidable penetrations and ensure transitions and flashings are designed conservatively
4) Wind performance
Wind performance is driven by:
-
Attachment and fastening schedule
-
Edge detailing at eaves and rakes
-
Underlayment and substrate decisions
-
Installer discipline at transitions and terminations
Both options can perform very well when installed correctly. If wind exposure is high, the best ROI is correct edge and transition detailing rather than splitting hairs between two premium shingle profiles.
5) Maintenance expectations
Premium metal shingles are typically low routine maintenance compared to many traditional materials. Most real-world issues that appear over time are caused by details, not the shingle profile:
-
Poorly detailed penetrations
-
Under-designed transition flashing
-
Misconfigured ventilation
-
Debris buildup in valleys and gutters
A simple ownership plan that prevents most problems
-
Inspect after severe storms
-
Keep valleys and gutters clear
-
Address flashing concerns early rather than waiting
6) Roof complexity and install realism
This factor often determines homeowner satisfaction.
If your roof is simple
Both DECRA Shingle XD and Westlake Granite Ridge can be excellent. In simple geometry, the choice is mostly aesthetics and resale positioning.
If your roof is complex
Your priority should be the system and detail plan that can be executed cleanly and consistently. Complex roofs multiply the impact of small installation errors. Choose the option your installer can detail correctly and avoid unnecessary penetrations when possible.
Resale value: how to think like a buyer
Resale value from a roof upgrade usually comes from three signals buyers pick up immediately:
-
The roof looks premium and intentional from the curb
-
The roof appears newer and well-maintained
-
The material implies long service life and lower future expense
DECRA Shingle XD resale logic
-
Clean, premium, widely acceptable shingle aesthetic
-
Often reads as a safe high-end upgrade without polarizing the look
Westlake Granite Ridge resale logic
-
More depth can create stronger curb appeal lift when it matches the home style
-
Best when neighborhood expectations support bold exterior upgrades
Simple decision rule for resale
Choose the profile that best fits your neighborhood and home architecture, then ensure the install is clean and consistent. Buyer confidence is driven by appearance and perceived quality more than brand name recognition.
Which one should you choose (fast checklist)
Choose DECRA Shingle XD if most of these are true
-
You want a clean, premium shingle look with broad buyer acceptance
-
Your home style is traditional or transitional
-
You prefer timeless aesthetics over bold texture
-
You want a crisp uniform appearance on large roof planes
Choose Westlake Granite Ridge if most of these are true
-
You want strong dimensional texture and shadow lines
-
Your home has prominent roof planes that benefit from depth
-
Your neighborhood supports bolder exterior upgrades
-
You want the roof to stand out visually
Compare the product pages side by side
DECRA Shingle XD: https://toptiermetals.com/products/decra-shingle-xd
Westlake Granite Ridge: https://toptiermetals.com/products/granite-ridge-shingle
FAQs
Is a premium metal shingle roof worth it for resale
Often yes, when the profile matches the home and neighborhood and the roof looks premium from the street. Buyers respond strongly to curb appeal and the expectation of reduced future roofing expense.
Which is better for hail, DECRA Shingle XD or Granite Ridge
In real outcomes, installation quality and detailing matter as much as product selection. For hail-prone areas, prioritize a system that can be detailed correctly and maintains appearance on your most visible roof planes.
Will a metal shingle roof be noisy
Noise is typically driven by the roof assembly: decking, underlayment, attic insulation, and ventilation. A properly built assembly usually does not create problematic interior noise.
What is the biggest mistake homeowners make choosing a metal roof
Choosing based on one factor like price or a brand name, while ignoring roof geometry, detailing plan, and installer capability. The best product installed poorly will underperform.
Shop Premium Metal Shingle Roofing
If you want to compare premium metal shingles and narrow to the right fit for your home style and priorities, start here:
