When it’s time to replace your roof, one of the biggest questions homeowners face is whether to choose metal roof tiles or asphalt shingles. Both options are popular for good reason — shingles are affordable and widely available, while metal tiles offer exceptional durability and modern style.
However, these two materials differ in nearly every key category, from lifespan and energy efficiency to cost and maintenance. This comprehensive guide breaks down the pros, cons, and costs of metal roof tiles vs. shingles, helping you make the best long-term decision for your home.
What Are Metal Roof Tiles?
Metal roof tiles are formed from steel or aluminum sheets designed to mimic the look of traditional roofing materials such as clay, slate, or concrete. They’re often coated with:
-
Stone granules (stone-coated steel) for texture and color variation.
-
PVDF paint finishes for a sleek, modern appearance.
Each tile interlocks with the next, creating a wind- and water-resistant barrier with concealed fasteners for a clean look.
Average lifespan: 40–70 years
Common materials: Galvanized steel, Galvalume®, aluminum
What Are Asphalt Shingles?
Asphalt shingles are fiberglass mats coated with asphalt and granules for waterproofing and color. They are the most widely used roofing material in North America.
Average lifespan: 15–30 years
Common types:
-
3-tab shingles (economy option)
-
Architectural/dimensional shingles (thicker, more durable)
-
Luxury shingles (heavier, premium aesthetic)
Lifespan and Durability
Metal Roof Tiles:
-
Lifespan of 50+ years with minimal maintenance.
-
Resistant to cracking, warping, rot, and insect damage.
-
Class 4 impact rating (the highest for hail resistance).
-
Handles winds of 120–140 mph.
-
Fire-resistant (Class A when installed properly).
Asphalt Shingles:
-
Lifespan 15–30 years, depending on climate and maintenance.
-
Prone to curling, cracking, and granule loss over time.
-
Can be damaged by hail or high winds.
-
Some fire-resistant options available, but limited durability overall.
✅ Winner: Metal roof tiles for strength and longevity.
Energy Efficiency
Metal Roof Tiles:
-
Reflect sunlight instead of absorbing it.
-
Helps reduce cooling costs in summer.
-
Optional batten systems create airflow for better insulation.
Asphalt Shingles:
-
Absorb heat, increasing attic temperatures.
-
May contribute to higher energy bills in warm climates.
-
Cool-roof rated shingles exist but are less efficient than metal.
✅ Winner: Metal roof tiles for thermal performance and energy savings.
Weight and Structural Impact
Metal Roof Tiles:
-
Lightweight (120–160 lbs per 100 sq. ft.).
-
Easy to install over existing roofs without structural reinforcement.
Asphalt Shingles:
-
Moderate weight (200–350 lbs per 100 sq. ft.).
-
Still lighter than traditional tile, but heavier than metal.
✅ Winner: Metal roof tiles — lightweight and versatile.
Cost Comparison
Metal Roof Tiles:
-
Material only: $6–$9 per sq. ft.
-
Installed total: $12–$18 per sq. ft.
Asphalt Shingles:
-
Material only: $1–$3 per sq. ft.
-
Installed total: $5–$8 per sq. ft.
While metal costs more upfront, it lasts 2–3 times longer — often making it the more cost-effective investment over 40–50 years.
✅ Winner: Asphalt shingles for upfront cost, metal tiles for lifetime value.
Aesthetic and Style Options
Metal Roof Tiles:
-
Mimic clay, slate, shake, or shingle profiles.
-
Dozens of color blends and textures.
-
Ideal for Mediterranean, contemporary, or luxury homes.
Asphalt Shingles:
-
Widely available in various colors and patterns.
-
More limited in texture and dimensional depth.
-
Familiar appearance suited for suburban homes.
✅ Winner: Metal roof tiles for architectural versatility and curb appeal.
Environmental Impact
Metal Roof Tiles:
-
Made from recycled steel or aluminum.
-
Fully recyclable at end of life.
-
Reflective surfaces reduce energy demand.
Asphalt Shingles:
-
Petroleum-based and difficult to recycle.
-
Typically end up in landfills.
-
Shorter lifespan increases material waste.
✅ Winner: Metal roof tiles for sustainability and recyclability.
Maintenance and Upkeep
Metal Roof Tiles:
-
Minimal maintenance: occasional inspection and cleaning.
-
No granule loss, cracking, or curling.
Asphalt Shingles:
-
Periodic inspection required for granule loss, leaks, and blown-off shingles.
-
Vulnerable to moss and algae growth in humid regions.
✅ Winner: Metal roof tiles for ease of maintenance.
Weather and Climate Performance
| Condition | Metal Roof Tiles | Asphalt Shingles |
|---|---|---|
| Heavy rain | Excellent | Good |
| High wind | Excellent (up to 140 mph) | Fair (often 90 mph limit) |
| Hail | Excellent (Class 4 rated) | Moderate |
| Snow/Ice | Excellent with snow guards | Moderate |
| Fire | Class A | Class A or B depending on product |
| Coastal salt exposure | Excellent (aluminum or coated steel) | Poor |
✅ Winner: Metal roof tiles for all-climate performance.
Resale Value and ROI
Metal Roof Tiles:
-
Increases home resale value by 3–6%.
-
Seen as a long-term, premium upgrade by buyers.
Asphalt Shingles:
-
Lower resale impact.
-
May need replacement before selling.
✅ Winner: Metal roof tiles for resale and long-term value.
Noise and Comfort Considerations
-
Metal roof tiles can be louder during rain or hail without proper insulation, but a high-quality underlayment greatly reduces sound.
-
Asphalt shingles naturally dampen sound, offering a quieter experience.
✅ Winner: Asphalt shingles for noise reduction (minor advantage).
Installation and Contractor Availability
Metal Roof Tiles:
-
Requires certified installers familiar with stone-coated or standing seam systems.
-
Fewer contractors specialize in metal roofing.
Asphalt Shingles:
-
Widely available and easy to install.
-
Lower labor costs.
✅ Winner: Asphalt shingles for ease of installation.
Side-by-Side Summary
| Category | Metal Roof Tiles | Asphalt Shingles |
|---|---|---|
| Lifespan | 40–70 years | 15–30 years |
| Cost (Installed) | $12–$18/sq. ft. | $5–$8/sq. ft. |
| Energy Efficiency | Excellent | Moderate |
| Maintenance | Low | Moderate |
| Fire Resistance | Class A | Varies |
| Hail/Wind Resistance | Excellent | Fair |
| Aesthetic Variety | High | Moderate |
| Environmental Impact | Recyclable | Non-recyclable |
| Noise Control | Moderate | Excellent |
| Ease of Installation | Moderate | Excellent |
| ROI | High | Moderate |
Which Roof Should You Choose?
Choose Metal Roof Tiles if:
-
You plan to stay in your home long-term.
-
You want premium curb appeal and lifetime durability.
-
You live in an area prone to hail, fire, or hurricanes.
-
You want an eco-friendly, low-maintenance solution.
Choose Asphalt Shingles if:
-
You’re on a tighter budget.
-
You need a fast, affordable roof replacement.
-
You plan to sell your home in the next few years.
Final Thoughts
When comparing metal roof tiles vs. shingles, both can protect your home well — but they serve different homeowner priorities. Asphalt shingles win for affordability and ease of installation, while metal tiles dominate in durability, beauty, and long-term value.
If your goal is to invest once and enjoy decades of performance, energy savings, and low maintenance, metal roof tiles are the superior choice.
For homeowners seeking short-term savings or simpler installation, asphalt shingles remain the practical go-to.
Either way, understanding these differences ensures you make a confident, informed roofing decision that fits your home, budget, and future goals.
