Metal tile roofing is the fastest way to get the architectural look of traditional tile with the durability and lighter weight of metal. But not all tile profiles look or perform the same in real-world installs.
This guide compares four premium profiles you can buy from Top Tier Metals: DECRA Tile metal tile roofing, DECRA Villa metal tile roofing, Westlake Barrel Vault metal tile roofing, and Westlake Pacific Tile metal tile roofing.
You will get a clear recommendation based on curb appeal, roof geometry, climate exposure, and the kind of tile look you want (Mediterranean, Spanish, coastal, or more refined high-detail architecture).
Quick section overview
- What makes metal tile roofing different
- Fast profile selector: which one fits your home style
- Side-by-side comparison table
- Best use cases for each profile
- Planning checklist: what to confirm before you order
- FAQ
What is metal tile roofing and why homeowners choose it
Tile-profile metal roofing is designed to replicate classic tile aesthetics while reducing the typical drawbacks of heavy clay or concrete tile. The big wins are usually:
- Lower structural load compared to traditional tile roofs
- High durability in hail, wind, and harsh weather (varies by system and assembly)
- Long-term curb appeal with consistent texture and shadow lines
- Architectural versatility that works on everything from Spanish to coastal to modern Mediterranean
If you are still deciding between tile, shake, shingle, or panel styles, start with the full roofing catalog: All Metal Roofing options at Top Tier Metals.
Fast profile selector: pick the best match for your style
Use this quick filter first, then confirm with the comparison table.
If you want a classic Mediterranean tile look with balanced profile depth
Start with DECRA Tile Mediterranean style metal tile roofing. It is a strong all-around option when you want recognizable tile patterning without an extreme high-barrel shape.
If you want an old-world, highly detailed tile appearance
Look at DECRA Villa old-world Italian style metal tile roofing. This profile is typically chosen when architecture needs a more premium, dimensional look.
If you want bold Spanish or Mediterranean high-barrel curb appeal
Choose Westlake Barrel Vault Spanish style high barrel metal tile roofing. This is the biggest visual statement of the four.
If you want a smoother tile look that reads coastal or tropical
Start with Westlake Pacific Tile coastal style metal tile roofing. It is often selected when the home needs tile character with a cleaner, lower-profile silhouette.
Comparison table: DECRA Tile vs DECRA Villa vs Barrel Vault vs Pacific Tile
| Profile | Visual look | Best architectural match | Best for roof geometry | Best when your priority is |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| DECRA Tile | Classic Mediterranean tile pattern | Mediterranean, transitional, traditional | Great general fit for many rooflines | Tile look + broad versatility |
| DECRA Villa | High-detail, old-world tile character | Luxury builds, European, high-end renovations | Ideal when aesthetics must carry the exterior | Premium curb appeal and architectural depth |
| Westlake Barrel Vault Tile | High-barrel clay tile replication | Spanish, Mediterranean, mission style | Strong visual impact on big roof planes | Bold style statement |
| Westlake Pacific Tile | Smoother Mediterranean tile profile | Coastal, tropical, lighter Mediterranean | Good for clean lines and modern exteriors | Refined tile look with a simpler silhouette |
Deep dive: how each metal tile profile typically fits real projects
DECRA Tile: the dependable Mediterranean look for most homes
DECRA Tile stone coated steel metal tile roofing is the profile many homeowners start with because it closely resembles classic Mediterranean tile while remaining broadly adaptable to different exteriors.
Choose DECRA Tile when:
- You want a recognizable tile pattern without going fully high-barrel
- Your home is Mediterranean or transitional and needs tile character without overpowering the facade
- You want a proven tile-profile option that is easy to visualize across common roof shapes
Recommended next step: compare colors and availability inside the curated tile collection: Metal Tile Roofing collection at Top Tier Metals.
DECRA Villa: premium architectural detail for luxury curb appeal
DECRA Villa premium metal tile roofing is the profile to consider when the roof is a major design feature. Villa is generally chosen to add richer shadow lines and a more refined tile aesthetic, often described as old-world or Italian-inspired.
Choose DECRA Villa when:
- The home has high-end finishes and the roof needs to match that level
- You want a more dimensional, premium tile look than a standard tile pattern
- You are upgrading curb appeal as part of a major renovation or new build
If you are narrowing down DECRA options, this hub keeps the brand portfolio in one place: DECRA Metal Roofing collection at Top Tier Metals.
Westlake Barrel Vault Tile: the bold Spanish high-barrel profile
Westlake Barrel Vault high barrel metal tile roofing is designed for homeowners who want the dramatic curvature of traditional Spanish clay tile. If your exterior architecture is built around that look, Barrel Vault tends to deliver the strongest match.
Choose Barrel Vault when:
- You want the most dramatic tile silhouette and deeper shadow lines
- Your home is Spanish, Mediterranean, or mission style where high barrel tiles look natural
- You have large roof planes and want the roof to read as a strong design element from the street
For more Westlake options beyond tile profiles, use the collection page as a catalog: Westlake Metal Roofing collection at Top Tier Metals.
Westlake Pacific Tile: smoother tile lines for coastal and modern Mediterranean
Westlake Pacific Tile luxury metal tile roofing is a strong choice when you want tile character with a smoother, more streamlined appearance than high-barrel profiles. This can complement coastal, tropical, and lighter Mediterranean design language where the roof should look premium but not heavy.
Choose Pacific Tile when:
- You want a tile look with a cleaner silhouette
- Your home leans coastal, tropical, or modern Mediterranean
- You want premium curb appeal without the highest-profile barrel look
How to decide in 5 practical questions
1) Do you want high-barrel drama or a more refined tile line?
- High-barrel statement: Westlake Barrel Vault Tile
- Refined tile line: Westlake Pacific Tile
2) Is your priority maximum architectural detail?
- Yes: DECRA Villa
- Moderate detail with broad fit: DECRA Tile
3) Does your neighborhood have a dominant roof style?
If most homes use Spanish clay tile, Barrel Vault is often the closest visual match. If the look is more modern coastal tile, Pacific Tile can fit better. If the area is mixed, DECRA Tile or DECRA Villa often blends cleanly without looking out of place.
4) How complex is your roofline?
Any tile-profile system requires careful planning around valleys, hips, ridges, penetrations, and transitions. If your roof has many planes or penetrations, focus on choosing the look you will love long-term and then confirm the full accessory and flashing plan with your installer.
5) Are you selecting for long-term resale appeal?
If resale and broad buyer appeal matters, the safest picks are often the profiles that read premium without being overly specific to one architectural theme. In many markets that points to DECRA Tile or Westlake Pacific Tile, depending on your home style.
Planning checklist before you order metal tile roofing
- Confirm your roof pitch and geometry so the profile, accessories, and layout plan are correct
- Match the profile to your architecture using reference photos and neighborhood context
- Choose color with real lighting in mind (sun exposure changes how blends read)
- Discuss ventilation and underlayment with your installer for the best assembly performance
- Plan the full system including ridges, hips, valleys, flashings, and penetrations
If you want to browse all four options in one place, the easiest starting point is the product collection page: Metal Tile Roofing products at Top Tier Metals.
FAQ: metal tile roofing profile selection
Which metal tile profile looks most like Spanish clay tile?
For the most traditional Spanish clay tile silhouette with a high-barrel look, Westlake Barrel Vault Tile is typically the closest match in this lineup.
Which option is best if I want a premium, high-detail roof appearance?
If your primary goal is rich architectural detail and a luxury tile aesthetic, start with DECRA Villa.
Which metal tile profile works best for coastal or tropical styles?
If you want a smoother tile look that fits coastal or tropical architecture, Westlake Pacific Tile is often the most natural fit.
Is DECRA Tile a safe all-around choice?
DECRA Tile is commonly selected as a versatile Mediterranean-style profile when you want tile character that adapts well across a wide range of home exteriors.
Do I need to think about more than the profile?
Yes. Profile drives curb appeal, but performance comes from the full roof assembly: layout, fasteners, underlayment, flashings, ventilation, and installation quality. Choose the profile you want to live with for decades, then validate the assembly plan with a qualified installer.
Ready to compare colors and options side by side?
Explore all tile profiles here: Shop Metal Tile Roofing at Top Tier Metals.
